We purchased a new car this weekend and listed our 15-year-old Toyota Corolla for sale on craigslist. Our car is in good running condition, but it definitely has its share of scrapes and cosmetic wear and tear. However, we figured there would still be a buyer for it somewhere. I have found that selling things on craigslist in LA generally takes much longer than when I used to sell things on craigslist in the Bay Area. Up there, I’d get buyers for things within hours of posting, but down here, the response time has always been much slower. So, I figured it would take weeks or longer before we actually managed to sell it. Given this assumption, I was surprised to get at least 12 responses in less than two hours. As I scrolled through the list of emails, I realized that they were all from people with non-English names, many of whom appeared to be immigrants of one kind or another. It made me think of the film, A Better Life, that I just blogged about. One of the people we spoke to was not a recent immigrant, but an elderly Italian man from New York who had just moved to LA to be near his son. He was in the middle of a family crisis, had no car, and was in a very desperate situation. He was the first person who responded, but needed a few hours to find a way to get to our location and literally begged us to hold the car for him.
As I took all this in, I had flashbacks to my case worker days where I heard these kinds of stories all the time. My heart swelled with compassion as I realized that there is a very large pool of people in society who need a reliable car now, regardless of what it looks like or how old it is or what make or model it is or what dings there are in the paint job, etc., all the meaningless things that people with resources waste emotional energy on. It almost made me want to just give the car away for free. It made me remember that need is relative. Yes, we have a need to sell the car to recoup some of the cost of buying a new one. But people in the market for old, used cars at bottom of the barrel prices have needs of a different magnitude.
I used to feel guilt as a young adult at these kinds of discrepancies. I was one of those self-aware children who was exposed regularly to people of different socio-economic backgrounds, including the poor in inner city Chicago. And so part of how I responded to the needs of the poor in my youth was to feel guilt for my own upbringing. But I realized afresh the other night that this is the incorrect response. The reality is, need is need, no matter what form it takes or where it is expressed. Needs extend across class and race barriers, across neighborhoods, families, varying life situations, etc. To be human is to experience felt needs of many kinds. So, no matter the source of the need, compassion is a better and more useful response than guilt. Yes, some needs are more severe than others, but there is no need that is not deserving of compassion. Compassion is just part of what it means to love. And love is always a good response, regardless of the particular life situation that is presenting itself.
So, we ended up selling the car to the man who was in crisis. He found a way to get to us and seemed very happy to have solved at least one of the many problems he was currently facing. It felt like a good exchange all around – our need to sell was met, as was his need to get a reliable car quickly, and it made me wish that these kinds of resource exchanges happened more frequently. There is something about in-person interactions that is so much more real and compelling than just connecting loosely to some larger organization or entity. In-person exchanges allow us to know a bit of one another’s stories. They remind us that we actually do have the ability to meet one another’s needs if we’re aware of them.